StoresPublished

What to look at after a store closes

Orders, average value, items and sizes. Six numbers that make the next store better, and the one that predicts whether it will be renewed.

  • 11 min read
  • 1,088 words
What to look at after a store closes — store retail at a print shop
Stores11 min readA1printsoft EditorialPhoto: Artem Beliaikin / Unsplash
On this page7 sections

The short answer

  • Participation rate — orders divided by people reached — is the number that matters
  • Track average order value; it tells you whether the price ladder worked
  • Sales concentrate at launch and in the final 48 hours; a flat middle is normal
  • Record which sizes ran short, or you will guess again next year
  • Ten minutes after each store compounds into a much better one next year

A store closes, the order is produced, and the whole thing is forgotten until next year — at which point everything is decided from memory. That is a waste, because a store generates exactly the data that would make the next one better, and collecting it takes ten minutes.

Why most shops do not look

Because the moment a store closes, the work starts. Consolidating, ordering blanks and getting the run scheduled absorbs everyone, and by the time it has shipped the store feels like history.

The fix is to make it part of closing rather than something afterwards. Export the numbers in the same hour you consolidate the order, and write them down then. The interpretation can wait; the capture cannot, because the store will be gone.

The six numbers

NumberTells you
Participation rateWhether distribution worked
Total orders and total valueThe headline, and the fundraiser's return
Average order valueWhether the price ladder worked
Items per orderWhether people bought more than one thing
Sales by itemWhat to keep and what to drop
Sizes ordered, and shortagesWhat to source deeper next time

Only the first requires anything the store does not already know — you need the size of the audience, which means asking the organiser how many people the link actually reached. Ask at close while they remember.

Reading participation

Orders divided by people reached. It is the only number that separates a store problem from a distribution problem, and without it every quiet store looks the same.

PatternMeans
Low participation, low ordersDistribution — the link did not reach people
Good participation, low ordersSmall audience; the store worked
Low participation, high trafficStore problem — price, choice or checkout
Good participation, good ordersRepeat exactly what you did

The third row is the only one where changing the store is the right response. In the first, redesigning would be solving the wrong problem — which is why distribution is the first thing to check on a store that underperformed.

Compare against the same customer's previous store rather than against other customers. A school and a company have completely different participation norms, and the useful comparison is with themselves last year.

Without participation, a quiet store and a small audience look identical.

The order curve

Plot orders by day. The shape is consistent and knowing it prevents unnecessary panic.

A spike at launch as the announcement circulates, a long flat middle where almost nothing happens, and a second spike in the final forty-eight hours as the deadline lands. Roughly a third of orders arrive in that last window.

Two practical consequences. A quiet middle is normal and not a reason to intervene. And if your curve has no closing spike, either the close date was not communicated or it was not believed — which is a fixable failure and the most common one.

Note when the organiser sent each reminder against that curve. The correlation is usually obvious, and it is the most persuasive thing you can show them when asking them to send three messages next time.

Items and sizes

Sales by item tells you what to cut. Nearly every store has one line that barely sells, and dropping it makes the next store simpler to run and slightly better converting, because there is one less decision.

Sizes tell you what to source. Record what was ordered and anything that ran short at the supplier, because those are different facts — a size nobody ordered may have been unavailable rather than unwanted.

Worth recording per store

  • Units by item, ranked
  • Units by size, per item
  • Any size that was short at the supplier
  • Any substitution made, and whether the customer minded
  • How long sorting actually took
  • Anything that went wrong, and why

The sorting time is the one that changes your scheduling. Most shops underestimate it substantially on a named order, and a real figure from last year is worth more than an estimate — it is the difference between a delivery date you can hold and one you hope for.

Using it next time

What last year's numbers change

  • Product list — drop the slowest, keep the rest
  • Stock — order deeper on sizes that ran short
  • Price ladder — add a premium item if average order value was flat
  • Promotion — show the organiser the curve against their reminders
  • Schedule — book real sorting time, not optimistic time
  • Close date — keep the window, it is not the variable

Keep it against the customer so next year starts from evidence rather than the same conversation. That is the same principle as storing everything a reorder needs — the second time should be easier than the first, and it only is if somebody wrote down what happened.

Send the organiser a short summary too. A school treasurer who receives the total raised, what sold, and a suggested date for next year is being given something useful — and a store that closes with a plan attached tends to be renewed without anyone having to sell it. The rest of the stores archive assumes you captured the numbers before the store disappeared.

Comparing stores against each other

Once you have run several, the comparison across customers becomes useful — but only on the right measures. Total value tells you how big the audience was, not how well the store performed.

Participation rate and average order value are the two that compare fairly. A school of 300 and a company of 40 produce very different totals, and a participation rate lets you see which store actually worked.

Worth comparing across customers

  • Participation rate — the fairest single measure
  • Average order value against the price ladder you offered
  • Items per order, which reflects catalogue design
  • Share of orders in the final 48 hours, which reflects the close date

Where one customer's store consistently outperforms, look at what their organiser does differently. It is almost always distribution — more reminders, a better channel, a launch tied to an event — and it is the most transferable thing you will learn.

Filed underStores
Share
Written byA1printsoft Editorial
175 articles

The print production desk at A1Printsoft. Writes the practical side of running a decorating shop: what things cost, how long they take and what to charge, checked against published trade figures.

Keep reading

More on stores

All Stores articles

Set up in an afternoon. From what you already do.

Free for 14 days · no card · pick what you make and we preload the methods, products and price tables.