BusinessPublished

Which orders to turn down

Saying yes to everything is why the schedule is full and the bank balance is not. The five kinds of order that cost more than they pay.

  • 11 min read
  • 1,084 words
Which orders to turn down — business office at a print shop
Business11 min readA1printsoft EditorialPhoto: Vitaly Gariev / Unsplash
On this page6 sections

The short answer

  • A full schedule at thin margin looks identical to a healthy one from inside
  • Turn down: below-minimum orders, impossible deadlines, unclear specs, chronic late payers and scope creep
  • Test an order on margin, capacity and risk before accepting it
  • Decline warmly and quickly — a fast no is a service
  • Capacity freed from bad work is the cheapest growth available

Most decorating shops accept nearly every order they are offered. The instinct is sound in the early years, when any work is better than none and every customer might become a good one. Carried into an established shop it becomes the main reason the schedule is full and the margin is not.

The difficulty is that bad orders do not announce themselves. They arrive looking like work.

Why does saying yes feel safe?

Because the cost of accepting is deferred and the cost of declining is immediate. Turning something down means a slightly awkward conversation now. Accepting means a rushed job in three weeks, and by then it does not feel connected to the decision.

There is also a scarcity reflex that outlives the conditions that produced it. An owner who spent two lean years taking everything keeps taking everything after the shop is busy, because the habit was formed when it was correct.

The clearest symptom is a very high quote-to-order rate. If you win almost everything you quote, you are either the cheapest in your market or accepting work others declined — and both are worth knowing. That is why the rate is worth tracking.

The five to turn down

1. Below your minimum. A six-piece screen order carries the same setup as a two-hundred-piece one, and setup does not shrink. Either price it properly, route it to a digital process, or decline it. What loses money is running it at a price built for a different quantity.

2. Impossible deadlines. Not tight — impossible. A job that requires everything to go right, with no room for a supplier delay or a reprint, will occasionally go wrong, and when it does you have failed publicly at something you should not have accepted.

3. Unclear specifications. A customer who cannot say what they want, on what garment, by when, is not ready to order. Accepting anyway means you absorb the discovery work, and the specification will change after you have bought blanks.

4. Chronic late payers. Your records already know who these are. An order from a customer who took ninety days last time is a loan, not a sale, and it is funded out of the same cash that pays for everyone else's blanks.

5. Scope creep as a pattern. Some customers change the job repeatedly after approval — an extra colour, a different garment, a new placement. One round is normal. A pattern of it means every job costs you two or three times the art and setup you priced.

A full schedule is not the goal. A full schedule of work that pays is.

How do you test an order?

Three questions, in under a minute, before you quote rather than after.

TestAskFail means
MarginDoes it clear my floor after setup and art?Reprice or decline
CapacityCan it be made without displacing better work?Offer a later date
RiskWhat happens if one thing goes wrong?Add time, or decline

The capacity test is the one shops skip and it is where the real damage happens. An order accepted into a full week does not simply add work — it pushes other jobs, and those jobs belong to customers who were told a date. One badly timed acceptance can put three deliveries at risk, which is a far larger cost than the margin on the new order.

How do you decline well?

Quickly, warmly, and without a lecture. A customer told no within an hour can go elsewhere and still think well of you. One left waiting three days for a soft no has been let down twice.

Four that work

  • Below minimum: "Our minimum on screen printing is 24. For six I'd print them digitally at $X each — happy to quote that if it helps."
  • Impossible date: "I can't do the 14th and be confident. I can do the 21st, or the 14th on a simpler one-colour version. Which is more useful?"
  • Unclear spec: "Once you know the garment and the quantity, send it over and I'll turn a quote around the same day."
  • Full week: "I'm full through the 20th. If your date can move I'd like the job; if not, I'd rather say so now than let you down."

Notice that three of the four offer an alternative. Declining an order is not the same as declining a customer, and a no that comes with a route forward keeps the relationship open for a job you do want.

When should you take the bad order anyway?

Deliberately, and knowing what it costs. Three cases are defensible.

A strategic first order from an account whose ongoing work you want. Take it, price it honestly, and treat the thin margin as acquisition cost rather than pretending it is profitable.

Filling genuine idle capacity. An order that covers its variable costs and uses hours that would otherwise be empty contributes something. That reasoning only holds when the capacity is truly idle — used to justify work in a full week, it is how shops talk themselves into everything.

An existing customer's occasional awkward job. A good account with a small urgent request is buying goodwill you will draw on. Once. A pattern is a pricing conversation.

What actually changes when you start declining?

Less chaos and roughly the same revenue, which surprises people. The orders that disappear are the small, urgent, unclear ones that consumed disproportionate attention, and the hours they occupied get filled by work that pays.

Watch over a quarterExpect
Order countDown
Average order valueUp
On-time rateUp
Reprint rateDown
RevenueRoughly flat, then rising

Track those rather than trusting the feeling, because the feeling in month one is that you are losing business. You are — specifically the business that was subsidised by everything else. Having the numbers in front of you is what makes the second month easier, and it is why the whole exercise depends on recording quotes and outcomes rather than remembering them. The rest of the business archive assumes you would rather choose your work than receive it.

Filed underBusiness
Share
Written byA1printsoft Editorial
175 articles

The print production desk at A1Printsoft. Writes the practical side of running a decorating shop: what things cost, how long they take and what to charge, checked against published trade figures.

Keep reading

More on business

All Business articles

Set up in an afternoon. From what you already do.

Free for 14 days · no card · pick what you make and we preload the methods, products and price tables.